Historic homes tell a story—but when the roof fails, that story can come to a premature end.
Your home is more than where you live. It’s a chapter in North Carolina’s architectural legacy. And like handcrafted moldings or original windows, your roof plays a critical role in preserving that character. Choosing the wrong roofing material can strip away the charm—or worse, cause costly, long-term damage.
Preserving the charm of your historic home doesn’t mean sacrificing performance—you just need the right materials.
Why Roofing Material Matters for Historic Homes
Every historic home was designed with intent. Architectural styles—Georgian, Colonial, Craftsman, or Spanish Revival—each have distinct roofing profiles, colors, and materials. Using the wrong type can diminish curb appeal, violate preservation rules, or result in expensive repairs.
The National Park Service’s Technical Preservation Services provides trusted guidelines for homeowners restoring historic structures, including roofing best practices.
The ideal material will:
- Complement your home’s historical style
- Meet modern performance standards
- Stand up to North Carolina’s demanding climate
For a deeper dive into restoration, read our blog: What Is Historical Restoration and Why Is It Important?
Common Roofing Materials for Historic Homes
Slate
Elegant, natural, and incredibly durable—lasting 75–100 years. Slate suits Georgian, Colonial, and Gothic Revival homes. However, its weight often requires structural reinforcement.
Cedar Shake or Shingles
A perfect match for Craftsman and Cottage-style homes. Cedar’s rustic warmth adds visual texture, but it needs ventilation and upkeep in NC’s humid climate.
Standing Seam Metal
Historically accurate and modern at once, this option is popular for Greek Revival and Farmhouse designs. Metal roofs offer energy efficiency, longevity, and a clean aesthetic.
Clay Tile
Often found on Mediterranean and Spanish Colonial homes, clay tiles are visually striking but fragile and heavy. While less common in the Triangle, they make a strong impression.
Synthetic Slate or Shake
Designed to mimic natural materials without the weight or maintenance. These modern alternatives are increasingly approved by local preservation boards.
For a full comparison of roofing materials, including historic-friendly options, visit This Old House’s guide to roofing materials.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing
Authenticity vs. Practicality
Can your home handle the weight of slate or tile? Would a high-quality synthetic match the appearance while offering modern benefits?
Local Historic Regulations
If you live in a historic district like downtown Durham or Cary, you'll need to follow specific guidelines. Our team can help navigate these with confidence.
Durability in NC’s Climate
Think humidity, summer heat, and hurricane season. Not all materials are created equal—Pickard Roofing only recommends those that are proven to last.
Maintenance Expectations
Natural materials like cedar and slate require regular upkeep. If you value lasting performance and are committed to preservation, they’re well worth the investment.
Bonus: The National Park Service’s Technical Preservation Services provides trusted guidelines for homeowners restoring historic structures, including roofing best practices.
When to Replace a Historic Roof
Watch for these red flags:
- Curling or missing shingles
- Moss or algae growth on wood or slate
- Water stains in attics or upper walls
- Crumbling mortar around clay or slate tiles
- Sagging or uneven rooflines
- Past renovations that already compromised historical accuracy
Ready to talk to a professional? Browse at our historical roofing page first.
Why Experience Matters
Restoring a historic roof isn’t like installing a new one on a modern home. Materials, techniques, and regulations differ—and mistakes can be irreversible.
At Pickard Roofing, we understand the nuances of historic restoration. We’ve helped homeowners across the Triangle preserve their homes with care, craftsmanship, and precision.
Learn what pitfalls to avoid in our guide: 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Restoring a Historic Roof
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use modern materials on a historic home?
Yes. Many synthetic products are approved in historic districts—but you’ll need guidance to make the right choice.
How do I know what kind of roof my home originally had?
Old photos, historical records, and neighboring homes can provide clues. Our team can help identify style-appropriate solutions.
Is it more expensive to roof a historic home?
Typically, yes. Materials are specialized and craftsmanship matters. But preserving your home’s value and integrity makes it a worthwhile investment.
Do I need approval to replace my historic roof?
If you're in a designated historic district, the answer is likely yes. We’ll help you through the approval process.
Old Homes Deserve the Right Roof
Your home is a piece of North Carolina’s story—and it deserves a roof that honors its history while protecting its future.
At Pickard Roofing, we’ve spent decades preserving the past while building roofs that stand strong for generations. If you’re ready to restore or upgrade your historic roof, we’re ready to help.
Contact Pickard Roofing to start your historic roofing project with craftsmanship that respects tradition—and protects what matters most.
